Criminal Defence · Hyderabad
Defending a False Section 498A Complaint
A Section 498A complaint, now Section 85 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, survives only if the prosecution proves cruelty as the statute defines it, and where the allegation is dowry-related, an unlawful demand for property made to the woman or her relatives. General allegations that the whole family harassed her are not evidence. A person facing a false complaint has lawful remedies at four stages: before arrest, at bail, by quashing the FIR in the High Court, and at discharge. This guide sets out each stage, the standards the Supreme Court has laid down, and the conduct that damages a defence.
What the complainant must prove
Section 85 BNS, which replaced Section 498A IPC from 1 July 2024, punishes a husband or a relative of the husband who subjects a woman to cruelty, with imprisonment up to three years and a fine. Section 86 BNS carries the definition. The offence is complete only on one of two limbs: wilful conduct of such a nature as is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide, or to cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or health, mental or physical; or harassment with a view to coercing her or her relatives to meet an unlawful demand for property or valuable security.
Each limb requires something the complainant must actually establish. On the first limb, the conduct must be wilful conduct and the consequence must reach the statutory threshold; a bad-tempered husband, an argumentative household or an unhappy marriage is not cruelty. On the second limb, there must be a demand, that demand must be unlawful, and the harassment must be with a view to coercing compliance. A demand for money that a wife is legally obliged to contribute, or a request made without any harassment behind it, does not satisfy the section on its own.
The most important practical point is specificity. The Supreme Court has repeatedly said that allegations against every member of the husband\'s family, made in identical language with no distinct role, cannot support a conviction. In Preeti Gupta v State of Jharkhand (2010) 7 SCC 667 the Court warned that exaggerated versions of domestic incidents are common and that courts must scrutinise the complaint rather than accept it. In K. Subba Rao v State of Telangana (2018) 14 SCC 452 it held that a finding of cruelty requires specific overt acts attributed to each accused, not a roving inquiry into family life.
What the section does not cover
It does not cover matrimonial discord as such. Quarrels over where the couple should live, how money is spent, or how much time the husband gives his parents are the ordinary friction of a joint family, and the criminal law is not a forum for resolving them. Nor does it cover a demand that is lawful, or a complaint that describes injury without connecting it to any conduct by the named accused.
It also rarely reaches relatives who had no share in the household. A married sister living abroad, an aged grandfather, a brother who visited twice a year: unless the complaint attributes a specific act or demand to that person, the case against them is vulnerable at the threshold. This is where a defence begins, and it is why the first thing to examine is not the wife\'s motive but the texture of the complaint itself.
The 2023 directions on summons and arrest
Arnesh Kumar v State of Bihar (2014) 11 SCC 129 remains the foundation. For offences punishable with imprisonment up to seven years, the Court held that arrest is not to be made mechanically: the police officer must be satisfied that arrest is necessary under Section 41(1)(b)(ii) CrPC, must issue a notice of appearance under Section 41A where arrest is not required, and must record the reasons in a checklist. The Magistrate, in turn, must not authorise detention mechanically, and breach of these directions exposes the officer to contempt.
On 31 July 2023 the Supreme Court reinforced that framework in Md. Asfak Alam v State of Jharkhand, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 892. The High Court had refused anticipatory bail and directed the husband to surrender and seek regular bail. The Supreme Court set that order aside, held that bail ought ordinarily to have been granted once the charge sheet was filed and no impediment remained, and directed every High Court and Director General of Police to issue circulars to lower courts and police stations within eight weeks so that the Arnesh Kumar guidelines are actually followed, with compliance reported to the Court.
The statutory position has since moved in the same direction. Section 35(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita requires a notice of appearance where the offence is punishable up to seven years and arrest is not necessary, and Section 35(1)(b) requires the reasons for arrest, or for not arresting, to be recorded in writing. A husband who receives a 498A or 85 BNS complaint is therefore entitled to ask, in writing, why arrest is necessary at all. That question, asked early and politely, often changes the course of the case. The wider procedural background sits in the domestic violence guide.
Bail: non-bailable does not mean jail
Section 85 BNS is cognizable and non-bailable, which means bail is a matter of judicial discretion rather than an entitlement. It does not mean custody is the default. The court weighs the nature of the allegations, the maximum sentence, the accused\'s roots in the community, the risk of tampering with evidence or witnesses, and the accused\'s record. For a first-time accused with a settled address, a job and no history of violence, regular bail is ordinarily granted, often on the first hearing.
Where arrest is likely before the application can be heard, anticipatory bail under Section 482 BNSS, formerly Section 438 CrPC, is the correct route. A condition that the husband take his wife back into the matrimonial home cannot be imposed as the price of bail: in Kunal Choudhary v State of Jharkhand (December 2023) the Supreme Court set aside exactly such a condition, holding that it was neither a proper condition nor a ground to refuse relief. Conditions that restrain contact, surrender documents or require cooperation with the investigation are the usual and permissible ones.
Refusal of bail is not the end of the matter. A fresh application lies if circumstances change, and the High Court can be moved under Section 483 BNSS, formerly Section 439 CrPC. What damages a bail case is not the seriousness of the allegation but conduct: evading summons, contacting the complainant directly, or transferring assets after the complaint.
Legitimate defence strategies
A defence is built stage by stage, and each stage needs a different kind of material. The table below sets out what is available at each point and what it requires. Note that the same documents serve several stages, which is why collecting them early is worth more than arguing later.
| Stage | What can be done | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| Before arrest | Written request for a Section 35(3) BNSS notice, with reasons why arrest is unnecessary | Address proof, employment record, no prior criminal case |
| Anticipatory bail | Application under Section 482 BNSS before the Sessions Court or High Court | Undertaking to cooperate, documents already with the police, no flight risk |
| Quashing | Petition under Section 528 BNSS where the complaint discloses no offence | The FIR and charge sheet read as a whole, with no external evidence |
| Discharge | Application under Section 250 BNSS for want of sufficient ground | Documents that contradict the charge sheet on its own material |
| Trial | Cross-examination on contradictions, absence of injury, delay in complaint | Medical record, neighbours, bank and travel records, dated messages |
| Settlement | Joint compromise placed before the High Court with the quashing petition | A voluntary agreement, recorded before a court or mediator, never extracted |
Two defences are frequently run and rarely succeed on their own. The first is that the complaint is a reaction to a divorce petition or a maintenance claim. Motive is relevant, but a court will not throw out a genuine complaint because it was filed after a maintenance case; what matters is whether the conduct alleged actually occurred. The second is delay. Delay in filing is a factor a court weighs, especially where the parties lived together throughout, but it is not by itself fatal, because women often complain only after leaving the household.
What does work is a documented timeline. Rent receipts showing the couple lived separately during the alleged period, office records showing the husband was posted elsewhere, hospital records that contradict the injury described, and messages that show ordinary household conversation rather than coercion are the material that wins cases at the discharge stage. See how a domestic violence complaint is filed for the record the complainant side will be building in parallel.
The limits of a defence
A defence must stay lawful. Approaching the complainant directly, asking her to withdraw the complaint outside a court or mediation process, or offering money for a withdrawal can itself become an offence of obstructing justice, and it destroys credibility before any judge. Filing a counter-complaint that is invented, or producing a document that turns out to be fabricated, converts a good defence into a prosecution. A court will believe an accused who produces one honest bank statement more readily than one who produces ten suspicious ones.
Balance matters here for a reason that is not merely rhetorical. Section 498A was enacted because dowry harassment was being recorded as suicide and accidental death, and genuine complainants still depend on it. A false complaint and a true one look identical on paper until the evidence is tested, which is precisely why the law gives the accused bail, quashing and discharge rather than requiring him to prove his innocence at the police station. Using those remedies well is different from attacking the statute.
If children are involved, the criminal case and the custody case move on separate tracks, and statements made in one are read in the other. Consult on both together; the child custody guide explains how the Family Court weighs conduct, and the divorce guide sets out how cruelty is proved as a civil ground on the same facts.
Frequently asked questions
Can a 498A case be quashed if the wife withdraws?
Not automatically, because the offence is non-compoundable. The High Court can quash under Section 528 BNSS on the strength of a genuine settlement, following B.S. Joshi (2003) and Gian Singh (2012). The court usually wants the wife present, or her statement recorded before a magistrate, to satisfy itself that the withdrawal is voluntary.
Will the police arrest me as soon as the FIR is registered?
They should not. Arnesh Kumar (2014) and Md. Asfak Alam (2023) require the officer to record why arrest is necessary and to issue a notice of appearance under Section 35(3) BNSS where it is not. If an arrest is made without that record, the omission is a ground in the bail application and, in an appropriate case, in a petition against the officer.
What if the complaint names my parents and married sister?
Each of them needs a specific allegation of cruelty or of an unlawful demand. Identical averments against the whole family have been held insufficient by the Supreme Court in Preeti Gupta (2010) and K. Subba Rao (2018). A quashing petition limited to those relatives often succeeds even where the case against the husband continues.
Does a maintenance case prove the 498A complaint is false?
No. Maintenance proceedings and a cruelty complaint can both be genuine, and the pendency of one does not answer the other. What helps is inconsistency between the two: an affidavit in the maintenance case describing a peaceful marriage, followed by a complaint describing years of violence, is material a court will notice.
How long does a 498A trial take?
In the Hyderabad magistrates courts, a contested trial commonly runs three to five years, and longer if witnesses are repeatedly absent. That is why discharge and quashing matter more than trial strategy: both can end the case in months. Where the case survives to trial, the complainant\'s evidence usually closes within a year of framing charges.
Facing a 498A complaint and unsure of the next step?
Advocate Maryam Fatima appears in bail, quashing and discharge matters before the Magistrates and the Telangana High Court, and advises on the parallel divorce and custody proceedings. Consultations are available in English, Hindi and Urdu.
Call +91 96358 75831