Child Custody · International · Hyderabad
Child Abduction and the Hague Convention: India has Not Signed
India is not a party to the Hague Convention of 1980 on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, and there is no Indian statute that orders a child returned to another country. Instead, an Indian court decides custody on the welfare of the child, and a mother can obtain a guardianship order, an injunction against removal, deposit of the child's passport, and a Look Out Circular on the strength of a court order. Once the child has physically left India, however, no Indian order will bring the child back; the fight must move to the courts of the country where the child now is.
What the Hague Convention does, and what India's absence means
The Hague Convention of 25 October 1980 on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction is a treaty between contracting states, not a custody law. Where a child habitually resident in one contracting state is wrongfully removed to another, the authority of the second state must order the child's return, subject to narrow exceptions such as grave risk of harm, and custody is decided later in the country of habitual residence. The design assumes that both countries are parties and each has a Central Authority to process applications.
India is not a contracting state. India signed nothing in 1980, has not acceded since, and has not enacted an implementing statute. The consequence is mechanical rather than moral: a father who takes a child from Hyderabad to London cannot be met with a return application in the High Court of England and Wales, because the Convention applies only where both the requesting and the requested state are parties, and the English court has no mandate under it to send the child back. The reverse is equally true: a mother who brings a child from Dubai to Hyderabad cannot be ordered to return the child under the Convention, because India has no mechanism to apply it.
India has ratified the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, 1989, whose Article 3 makes the best interests of the child a primary consideration and whose Article 11 requires states to combat the illicit transfer and non-return of children abroad. That obligation has never been translated into a domestic return procedure, and draft legislation on inter-country removal has been circulated more than once without being enacted.
What Indian courts do instead: welfare, not automatic return
Indian custody law rests on two statutes and one principle. The Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 gives the District Court power to appoint or declare a guardian, Section 9 fixes jurisdiction where the minor ordinarily resides, and Section 17 lists the factors to be weighed, beginning with welfare. The Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, Section 13, states the same for Hindu children: welfare is paramount, and no guardian's right survives a conclusion that it is against that welfare. Muslim custody follows hizanat rules, but they too yield to welfare. Section 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act allows interim custody orders in a pending matrimonial petition.
What this means in a cross-border case is that there is no presumption of return and no presumption of retention. The court asks where the child will be safe, educated, cared for and stable, and it is willing to hear evidence about schools, medical care, housing, the earning capacity of each parent and the child's own wishes, weighted by age. A mother who has kept the child in Hyderabad without the father's consent is not automatically in the wrong; neither is a father who has taken the child to his home country. The court's question is what happens to the child next.
The unsettled question: comity against welfare
Where an Indian court is asked to send a child back to a foreign country whose courts have already made an order, the case law pulls in two directions, and it is better to say so than to pretend there is a rule. In Surya Vadanan v State of Tamil Nadu (2015) the Supreme Court ordered two children returned to the United Kingdom, holding that where a foreign court of competent jurisdiction has taken a custody decision, Indian courts should respect comity and ordinarily direct return unless the child's welfare clearly requires otherwise. In Nithya Anand Raghavan v State of NCT of Delhi (2017), on facts where a mother had brought a child from the United Kingdom, the Supreme Court declined to order return, holding that the welfare of the child is paramount and that comity, while relevant, cannot displace it.
The outcome turns on facts, not doctrine: the child's age, how long the child has lived where they are, whether the removal was concealed, and whether there is a foreign order and what it says. A parent who removed the child secretly and lied about the destination is treated far worse than one who left openly and filed promptly. Concealment is the fact that decides these cases.
The orders that can stop a child leaving India
The remedy that works is preventive. Indian immigration does not require a no-objection certificate from the other parent before a child departs on a valid passport with one adult, and airlines ask for such documents inconsistently. So the practical objective, where you fear removal, is a court order before the flight, not an application after it.
Start with a custody or guardianship petition before the Family Court at Hyderabad, which exercises custody jurisdiction under Section 7(1)(b) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, or a guardianship petition under the Guardians and Wards Act where a declaration of guardianship is needed. Move with it an application for an ex parte ad interim injunction restraining either parent from removing the child from the jurisdiction of the court, and an application for deposit of the child's passport with the court. Courts grant these where there is credible material — a booked ticket, a visa approval, a message saying the child will be taken, a school leaving certificate applied for.
Where a parent disobeys, or where an order already exists and there is material showing an attempt to leave, apply for a Look Out Circular. An LOC is generated by the immigration authorities on the request of an authorised agency, and a court order is the firmest basis for one; the Ministry of External Affairs and the Foreigners Regional Registration Office are the usual channels. Courts have also impounded passports to prevent removal.
If the child has been taken within India and is being held, the remedy is a habeas corpus petition under Article 226 before the Telangana High Court, which is heard urgently. If the taking amounts to removing the child from the lawful guardianship of the other parent without consent, a criminal complaint under Section 137 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, the successor to Section 361 of the Indian Penal Code, is possible. Courts are cautious about criminalising a parent in a custody dispute, but a complaint creates a record, an alert at ports in some cases, and leverage in the custody proceedings.
The measures compared
| Measure | What it actually does | Realistic timing |
|---|---|---|
| Interim injunction against removal | Binds the parent; contempt follows breach, but it does not bind an airline or immigration | Same day to a few days on an urgent application |
| Deposit of the child's passport | Removes the physical means of travel until the court releases it | With the injunction, at the first effective hearing |
| Look Out Circular | Alerts immigration at every Indian port of exit; needs an official request | Weeks; urgent requests move faster with a court order |
| Custody or guardianship order | Declares who has custody, and on what access terms; enforceable in India | Interim order in weeks; final order in one to three years |
| Habeas corpus in the High Court | Produces a child held within India and tests the legality of the detention | Listed within days where urgency is shown |
| Criminal complaint under Section 137 BNS | Creates a police record; may support an LOC; rarely ends in conviction between parents | Registration within days; trial takes years |
If the child has already been taken abroad
Then the Indian court is no longer the forum that can help, and it is worth being blunt about that. An Indian custody order has no direct operation in another country. A Dubai or London court will not enforce a Hyderabad order as a matter of course; it will decide afresh, or recognise the Indian order if its own rules permit. What you can still do in India is obtain a custody order and a declaration that the removal was wrongful, which becomes the foundation of the case you file abroad, and use the Indian proceedings to establish the facts: the concealment, the false address, the school withdrawal, the messages.
Abroad, your options depend on the country. In a Hague contracting state, the Central Authority route is unavailable where India is the habitual residence, because India is not a party, but the local court can still be asked to exercise its own welfare jurisdiction, and many courts will treat a unilateral removal in breach of an Indian order as a serious factor. In every case you need counsel in that jurisdiction, a translated and attested set of Indian orders, and evidence about the child's life before the removal.
Preserve the travel evidence: the ticket, the entry stamp, the school leaving certificate, the date the child's belongings were packed. Habitual residence and wrongful removal are proved by dates, and abandoning the Indian case hands the other parent an argument that you accepted the new arrangement. The wider framework is set out in the child custody guide.
Frequently asked questions
Is India a signatory to the Hague Convention on child abduction?
No. India is not a contracting state to the 1980 Convention and has enacted no law giving effect to it, nor is it party to the 1996 child protection Convention or the 2007 child support Convention.
Can an Indian court order my child brought back from Dubai?
No. An Indian court can decide custody and declare the removal wrongful, but it cannot enforce an order inside another country. If the child is in the UAE you must litigate there, using the Indian orders as evidence.
Does my husband need my consent to fly out with our child?
Not at the immigration counter. Once a child holds a valid passport, Indian immigration does not require a no-objection certificate from the other parent, though airlines ask inconsistently. That is why the preventive orders matter.
How do I get a Look Out Circular against my husband?
Through an authorised agency on the strength of a court order. Your lawyer applies in the pending custody case, and the order is communicated to the immigration authorities through the Ministry of External Affairs or the Foreigners Regional Registration Office.
My child has lived abroad for three years. Can I still get custody in India?
You can ask, and an Indian court will decide on welfare. But a settled life abroad, a school, friends and stability weigh heavily against uprooting a child, and courts have declined to disturb such arrangements.
Worried your child may be taken out of India?
Advocate Maryam Fatima files urgent custody, injunction and passport-deposit applications before the Family Court at Hyderabad. Bring the ticket, the messages and the dates. Consultations in English, Hindi and Urdu.
Call +91 96358 75831