Maintenance · Hyderabad
Proving Your Husband's Income in a Maintenance Case
You do not have to prove your husband's exact salary; you have to prove his means, and the court can order him to produce the documents that show them. Section 125 CrPC, now Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, fixes maintenance on his "sufficient means" and your inability to maintain yourself, not on a forensic audit of a payslip. Returns, Form 16, Form 26AS, bank statements, provident fund records and plain lifestyle evidence do that work, and where he withholds documents the court may draw an adverse inference against him.
The court asks about means, not maths
Section 125(1)(a) CrPC, now Section 144(1)(a) BNSS, speaks of a husband who has sufficient means and neglects or refuses to maintain his wife. The statute does not require you to establish a precise monthly figure. You must show three things: that he earns, that his earnings comfortably exceed his own needs, and that you cannot maintain yourself from your own income or property. Judges in Hyderabad work from that three-part framing in almost every maintenance order, and a wife who pleads it clearly is already ahead of one who simply names a number.
Means is wider than salary. It takes in allowances, the car, the rent he pays, the business he runs, the property he holds and the standard of living he actually maintains. A man declaring forty thousand rupees a month who pays eighty thousand in rent does not have forty thousand of means, and courts know it. In a Hindu marriage petition Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 uses different words, referring to his income and other property, but the inquiry is the same. In Rajnesh v Neha (2020) the Supreme Court required affidavits of disclosure of assets and liabilities from both parties; read his line by line against these documents.
The paper trail that decides most cases
Each record answers a different question, and no single one is enough.
| Document | What it establishes | Usual defect |
|---|---|---|
| Income tax returns, three years | Declared income, business turnover and profit | Returns filed late or nil to defeat the claim |
| Form 16 and Form 26AS | Salary from every employer, tax deducted by each | One employer shown, second job invisible |
| Bank statements, twelve months | Credits, rent paid, EMIs, card bills | Salary credited to a parent's account |
| Provident fund passbook and UAN | Employer, monthly basic, length of service | Never obtained because the UAN is unknown |
| Loan sanctions and card bills | Living standard, servicing capacity | Produced only to inflate deductions |
| Rent agreement and utility bills | Housing cost above the declared income | Agreement in a relative's name |
| Insurance and mutual fund statements | Surplus cash flow, savings capacity | Policies held in a parent's name |
| Passport pages and visa stamps | Travel he omits while pleading poverty | Copies not applied for in time |
Form 26AS deserves separate mention. It records tax deducted at source by every deductor against his PAN, so a second salary, director's remuneration or interest income appears even when the Form 16 from his main employer looks clean. The EPF passbook is its companion: it shows the monthly basic on which contributions were made, and a basic far above the salary he swears to is hard to explain. Documents you already hold cost nothing to file, including a photographed payslip, a jointly filed return or a rent agreement you both signed. The wider statutory background is in the maintenance guide.
When he will not produce: Section 94 BNSS
The usual position is that he files an affidavit claiming a modest salary and produces nothing to support it. You then ask the court to compel production. In a maintenance application before a Magistrate the route is Section 91 CrPC, now Section 94 BNSS, which empowers the court to summon a person to produce a document or thing. The Magistrate can direct the husband, and in an appropriate case his employer's accounts department, to produce salary slips, the salary register extract, the appointment letter and Form 16 for the relevant years. Nothing in the section limits it to criminal investigations.
Two cautions decide whether the application succeeds. Be specific: a prayer for all documents relating to his income invites refusal, while a prayer naming salary slips for January 2023 to December 2024 and Form 16 for two assessment years does not. And be careful with a private employer, who is a stranger to the matrimonial dispute; seek the documents from the husband first so that his refusal is on record. In a Family Court petition the same material comes through discovery and interrogatories under Order XI CPC, and short interrogatories on his employer, designation, gross salary and rent are hard to answer evasively. Muslim couples usually proceed under Section 144 BNSS instead; see the Muslim law guide.
Adverse inference when income is concealed
Concealment is a strategic mistake by the husband, not a dead end for you. Illustration (g) to Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, now Section 119 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, states the presumption that evidence which could be produced and is withheld would, if produced, be unfavourable to the person withholding it. That illustration is the legal basis for the submission made in almost every under-declared case: he has the returns and the statements, he has not produced them, and the court may presume they would have shown more than he swears to.
The inference is discretionary and is drawn more readily where you have pleaded a specific figure and the material behind it, sought production and met evasion, and can point to inconsistencies in his affidavit. Three consequences follow. The court may compute maintenance on the material before it rather than his stated income. It may refuse the deductions he claims, including large EMIs and payments to parents, where unsupported. And a false affidavit of disclosure exposes the deponent to proceedings for giving false evidence on oath. None of this happens without a written application that puts the material on record.
Lifestyle evidence most wives underuse
Documents prove what a man declares; lifestyle proves what he spends, and spending is the most reliable evidence of means because it is hard to fake downward for years. A man who takes his family to a resort, drives a financed car, sends his children to a school charging ninety thousand rupees a term and pays forty-five thousand in rent has a living standard that no affidavit of a thirty-thousand-rupee salary explains. That gap, documented and tabulated, is usually the whole case.
Collect lawfully, and organise by date: school fee receipts and the fee circular, coaching receipts, the rent agreement and transfer screenshots, car loan EMIs, club or gym memberships, insurance premium notices, photographs from family events, travel bookings, and anything he has posted publicly about a new job, office or car. Public posts are fair game; do not access his private accounts or phone, because evidence obtained unlawfully can damage your case more than it helps. Present it as a one-page schedule of monthly rent, fees and EMIs with a document against each line, not as fifty annexures.
From income to a figure the court will order
No statute fixes a percentage, and any lawyer who promises one is guessing. Hyderabad courts work from net take-home pay rather than gross, deduct obligations that are genuine and documented, then fix a share that leaves the wife and children near the standard of living they had. A wife living separately is often awarded something in the region of a quarter of his net income, with a further component where children live with her, but that is an argument, not a rule. Ask for school and medical expenses to be paid directly, in addition to the monthly sum.
Plead the date from which you want maintenance. An order under Section 144 BNSS is ordinarily payable from the date of the order, and the court has power to direct payment from the date of the application where the material supports it, but that relief must be asked for and argued. If he defaults afterwards, the remedy is enforcement in the same court, described in recovering maintenance arrears. If you need money while the case is pending, the quicker route is an application for interim maintenance, covered in interim maintenance in Hyderabad.
Frequently asked questions
Can the court force my husband to produce his salary slips?
Yes, if you ask properly. A Magistrate can summon documents from him, and in an appropriate case from his employer, under Section 91 CrPC, now Section 94 BNSS. In a Family Court petition the same material is obtained through discovery and interrogatories under Order XI CPC. Name the specific documents and periods; a general demand for all income records is usually refused.
My husband is paid in cash. What do I do then?
Cash income is proved by what it buys. Rent, school fees, EMIs, insurance premiums, travel and the size of the household are documented somewhere, and spending well above declared income supports an inference that the declaration is incomplete. Where he runs a business, the GST registration, shop rent deed, supplier invoices and merchant credits are often more useful than any salary document.
Is his income tax return enough proof of his income?
It is strong evidence but not conclusive, because a return can be filed late, filed nil or understated. Read it with Form 26AS, the provident fund passbook and the bank statements. Where the return shows a modest income and the statements show large unexplained credits, the court is entitled to prefer the bank records.
His salary goes into his mother's account. Does that defeat my claim?
Not necessarily. Section 144 BNSS looks at his means, not at whose name is on the account. If the credits are regular, if he operates the account, or if the family's expenses are met from it, the court can treat the money as his. Evidence that he signed the account opening form, holds the debit card or that the account pays his premiums and car loan turns the argument.
From which date will maintenance be ordered?
An order under Section 144 BNSS is ordinarily payable from the date of the order, and courts have power to direct payment from the date of the application where the facts justify it. Plead the earlier date expressly and file early, because every month between separation and filing is a month of maintenance that must be argued for rather than assumed.
Not sure what your husband is actually earning?
Advocate Maryam Fatima prepares disclosure applications and maintenance claims for the Family Court at Hyderabad, and advises on what to collect before the first hearing. Consultations are available in English, Hindi and Urdu.
Call +91 96358 75831