Hyderabad, Telangana

Settlement · Hyderabad

The Mediation Report and What Happens Next

A mediation report is the mediator's written account of what the parties agreed, and it comes in one of three forms: settled, where a signed settlement disposes of every issue; partially settled, where some issues are agreed and the rest go back to the judge; and not settled, where no agreement was reached and the case returns for trial. The report is not a judgment and it does not decide anything by itself, but it is the first document a Family Court judge reads about your case after the pleadings, and a careless signature on a memorandum of agreement can end a claim you did not intend to give up. In Hyderabad the reference is normally made under Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 read with Section 9 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, at the first or second hearing.

Mediation inside the Family Court

Family Courts in Telangana are required by Section 9 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 to make an effort, in the first instance and wherever it is possible, to assist and persuade the parties to arrive at a settlement. In a Hyderabad matrimonial case that effort usually takes a concrete form: the judge refers the parties to the court-annexed mediation centre attached to the Family Court or to the district mediation centre, names a mediator from the panel or a referral judge, and adjourns the case for a fixed period.

The reference is made under Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which allows a court, where it finds elements of a settlement that may be acceptable to the parties, to formulate the terms of settlement and refer the dispute to arbitration, conciliation, judicial settlement including a Lok Adalat, or mediation. Because Section 10 of the Family Courts Act applies the Code to proceedings before it, the machinery carries over into matrimonial matters, subject to the special procedure the Act itself lays down.

Mediation is confidential and structured: the mediator meets the parties, sometimes together and sometimes separately, and does not record evidence. Unlike a Lok Adalat award, mediation does not produce a decree: it produces a report and, where the parties agree, a memorandum of agreement that the court must then act upon. What happens inside the mediation room stays out of the record; what happens to the file depends entirely on the report.

How the report is actually written

A mediation report is a short document. It identifies the case number, the parties, the mediator, the dates of the sittings, the number of sessions, and the outcome. Where the parties have agreed, it states that the matter has been settled and attaches the memorandum of agreement, which is signed by both parties and by the mediator, and which sets out the terms paragraph by paragraph. Where no agreement was reached, it records that the mediation failed and, in most centres, notes the issues that were discussed without disclosing the offers made.

The report reaches the judge in a sealed cover or is filed on the docket, and the case comes back on the board. Under Section 89 and the reported decisions of the Supreme Court the court retains a supervisory role: it satisfies itself that the settlement is lawful, voluntary and not unconscionable before it passes an order or a decree in its terms. A settlement that would leave a wife with nothing and no right to return to court can be refused, and courts have refused such terms.

Practical point that decides most of the cases I see: the memorandum of agreement, not the report, is the operative document. If the memorandum is vague, the court cannot supply the missing term, and you will be left arguing about what you meant three years later. Read the memorandum twice before you sign, and never sign a blank or partly filled page on the assurance that the mediator will complete it.

When the report says settled

A settled report means every issue in the litigation has been resolved. In a divorce petition that means the ground or the consent, the maintenance figure, the return of stridhan, the custody and access arrangements, and the fate of any other pending proceedings between the couple. The judge then passes a decree in terms of the settlement, and the decree is enforceable in the ordinary way, by execution.

A settled report is not automatically a divorce either. In a mutual consent matter the settlement does not dispose of the petition until the second motion is recorded and the court is satisfied that consent subsists. In a contested petition, a full settlement is a ground for the court to convert the matter into a decree of dissolution, and courts commonly do so where both parties sign. What a settlement cannot do is create a divorce where the statute requires a judicial finding and one party backs out before the decree is pronounced.

Check three things before the settled report is filed. First, that the memorandum deals with every pending case number, including a maintenance application under Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 or a domestic violence application, because a case left out survives by default. Second, that any obligation which takes time to perform has a date attached to it. Third, that the settlement says expressly whether a party may apply for variation if circumstances change, because a silent settlement tends to be read as final.

When the report says not settled

A not settled report is the ordinary outcome in most contested matrimonial cases and it carries less weight than clients fear. The judge does not read it as evidence that you were unreasonable, and the offers exchanged in mediation are not evidence in the trial. The case simply resumes: the court frames the issues, sets a schedule for affidavits of evidence, and the matter proceeds to trial with witnesses and cross-examination.

Where the mediator records that some facts are not in dispute, the court may narrow the issues, and where the report notes that a party failed to attend sittings without reason, the court may take that into account on costs. A husband who refuses to attend mediation is also a husband whose conduct the court has now noticed in writing, which is often useful in a maintenance application where conduct is relevant to the urgency of interim relief.

If mediation failed because your husband demanded terms you cannot accept, the useful next step is usually an interim application rather than waiting for trial. Interim maintenance can be sought so that the litigation is funded while it runs, and the fact that mediation broke down over money is exactly the material a court considers when fixing that interim figure.

Partly settled: the most common outcome

A partially settled report means the parties agreed on some issues and left the rest to the court. The typical pattern is agreement on the money and disagreement on the child, or agreement on custody and disagreement on the valuation of property. The report attaches a memorandum covering only what was agreed and records that the remaining issues could not be resolved.

This is often the best result, but it has a trap. A partial memorandum that fixes maintenance at a monthly figure in exchange for the wife giving up her claim to the matrimonial house may be recorded as a settlement of those issues even though the wife believed the property question was still open. Read the recitals, not just the operative paragraphs, because concessions hide there.

Where the partial settlement covers children, be careful about interim access. A memorandum that grants weekend access during the pendency is not the same as a final custody arrangement, and the court will treat it as an interim understanding only if the document says so. Expect the other side to argue that you have already conceded the custody pattern.

How the report shapes the trial

The table below sets out what each outcome means for the file, and what to check before the court acts on it.

Report outcome What the court does next What to check before it is recorded
Settled Takes the memorandum on record and passes a decree in its terms, disposing of the petition Every pending case number is named; every payment has a date
Partially settled Records the agreed issues, frames the rest for trial and proceeds on the unresolved issues That the recitals do not quietly concede an unresolved claim
Not settled Frames issues, sets a schedule for evidence and lists the case for trial Whether interim maintenance should be moved at once
Party absent Records non-attendance, may impose costs and normally closes the mediation reference That your own attendance is documented on every date

Beyond the immediate order, the report has a subtler effect. It reaches the judge before the evidence does, and a settlement memorandum that recites that the wife has been maintained by her parents, or that she left the home of her own accord, becomes part of the court's first picture of the marriage. Those recitals are not proof, but they are read. This is why a woman should never sign a memorandum drafted entirely by the other side simply because its money terms look acceptable.

For the wider picture of how the two routes compare in cost and time, see the mediation versus litigation comparison. For the sequence of hearings that follows a failed mediation, the Family Court procedure guide sets out the stages, and the child custody guide explains what a court looks at when custody is the issue left open.

Frequently asked questions

Is mediation compulsory in a Hyderabad family court case?

Not compulsory, but it is close to routine. Section 9 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 requires the court to attempt a settlement in the first instance, and judges commonly refer matrimonial matters to mediation before framing issues. You can decline to settle, and you can say that you are willing to mediate but not on the terms proposed.

Can what I say in mediation be used against me in court?

The mediation process is designed to be confidential and the report is expected to record outcomes rather than the offers exchanged, so a concession made in the room is not evidence at trial. The safe assumption, however, is that the memorandum you sign will be read in full.

Can I be forced to accept a settlement I do not want?

No. A settlement requires your signature, and a court will not pass a decree on terms to which a party has not consented. Pressure inside the room, including pressure from family members present, is a reason to ask for a separate session and an adjournment.

How long does the mediation stage take?

Mediation references in Hyderabad are usually listed for a fixed period of about sixty days, with sittings every week or fortnight, and the report is expected within that window. Extensions are granted where the parties are close to agreement.

If mediation settles everything, do I still need a second motion?

In a mutual consent petition, yes. The settlement does not replace the statutory requirement that the court record consent at the first motion and be satisfied at the second motion, after the cooling-off period or a valid waiver, that the consent subsists.

Need the memorandum checked before you sign?

Advocate Maryam Fatima reviews mediation settlements and appears before the Family Court at Hyderabad. Consultations are available in English, Hindi and Urdu.

Call +91 96358 75831
Keep reading

Related legal guides

More answers on the same area of family law, written for clients in Hyderabad.

Browse all legal guides →

Call WhatsApp Book Visit