Divorce · India
Withdrawing a Mutual Consent Divorce in India
Consent to a mutual-consent divorce is not irrevocable. Under Section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, mutual consent must subsist until the decree is passed, and either party may unilaterally withdraw consent at any time before that decree. The leading authority is Sureshta Devi v Om Prakash (1991), where the Supreme Court held that the court has no jurisdiction to dissolve the marriage by consent once consent is withdrawn. The practical effect turns on the stage: withdrawal before the second motion is moved normally ends the petition, while withdrawal at or after the second motion is far harder to sustain. This guide sets out the rule, the difference between the two motions, and what happens when one party simply stops attending.
The two-stage structure of a mutual-consent divorce
Section 13B(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 allows both parties to a marriage to present a joint petition on the ground that they have been living separately for one year or more, that they have not been able to live together, and that they have mutually agreed that the marriage should be dissolved. Section 13B(2) then provides that on the motion of both parties, if the petition is not withdrawn in the meantime, the court, after hearing the parties and making such inquiry as it thinks fit, and after being satisfied that the averments are true and that the consent was not obtained by force, fraud or undue influence, shall pass a decree of divorce. The petition, then, does not by itself end the marriage; a second step is required.
That structure is why a consent divorce has two hearings that matter, and why a client who changes their mind needs to know at which stage they stand. A petition filed and not yet followed by a second motion is a live proceeding in which the parties may still separate their ways. Once the second motion has been heard and the court is satisfied, the window closes. Everything about withdrawal of consent is a question of where in that sequence the party stands when the mind changes.
What Section 13B(2) actually says
The operative words are "on the motion of both parties, if the petition is not withdrawn in the meantime". Two things follow. First, the second motion must be by both parties, not one; a motion by a single party does not satisfy the section. Second, the section itself contemplates that the petition may be withdrawn before the motion, which is the textual basis for the right to resile. The second motion may be made not earlier than six months and not later than eighteen months after the date on which the petition was presented, and the six-month period is directory rather than mandatory: in Amardeep Singh v Harveen Kaur (2017) the Supreme Court held that a court may waive it where the settlement is complete, the parties have genuinely lived apart for over a year, and reconciliation is impossible.
The words "if the petition is not withdrawn in the meantime" are sometimes read as if the only way to withdraw were a formal application. In practice a party withdraws consent by stating so before the court, by an affidavit, or simply by refusing to join the second motion. The court is then left with a consent divorce in which consent has gone, and the section gives it no power to proceed. The remedy is not to force a decree but to dismiss the petition, leaving the parties free to file a fresh consent petition later or to pursue other relief.
Is consent irrevocable? The rule in Sureshta Devi
The question went to the Supreme Court in Smt Sureshta Devi v Om Prakash (1991) 2 SCC 25. The spouses had filed a joint petition under Section 13B, and their statements were recorded; within about a week the wife applied to withdraw, alleging her consent had been obtained under pressure. The District Judge dismissed the petition, but the High Court granted a divorce on the reasoning that consent once given could not be withdrawn. The Supreme Court reversed the High Court and restored the dismissal.
The Court held that filing a petition under Section 13B(1) does not by itself authorise the court to dissolve the marriage, and that the parties must move a joint motion under sub-section (2). The interregnum of six to eighteen months exists precisely to allow reflection. Mutual consent is a sine qua non for a decree under Section 13B and must continue until the decree is passed; if at the inquiry one party says consent is withdrawn, the court's jurisdiction to grant a divorce by consent is not made out. The Court expressly affirmed the view of the Kerala, Punjab and Haryana, and Rajasthan High Courts and overruled the contrary view of the Bombay, Delhi and Madhya Pradesh High Courts. That is the rule that governs today.
The leading judgments after Sureshta Devi
Two later decisions matter, and it is important to read them for what they actually decided. In Ashok Hurra v Rupa Bipin Zaveri (1997), the Supreme Court used its power under Article 142 of the Constitution to dissolve a marriage that had irretrievably broken down, even though the parties had not proceeded to a consent decree; the case shows that in exceptional cases the Supreme Court itself may end a marriage that consent cannot, but it does not give a Family Court a general power to ignore a withdrawal. Then in Shilpa Sailesh v Varun Sreenivasan (2023), a Constitution Bench confirmed that the Supreme Court may, under Article 142, dissolve a marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown and waive the waiting period, while at the same time holding that this power cannot be used mechanically and that the statutory grounds and procedures remain the framework. These cases do not disturb Sureshta Devi: before a Family Court, a withdrawn consent still defeats a Section 13B petition.
The practical lesson is that the withdrawal right operates within the consent route. A spouse who withdraws consent under Section 13B forces the other to choose between a fresh consent petition and a contested petition on fault grounds under Section 13(1). It is the other party's litigation to restart, and that is a real cost that both sides should weigh before either resiles.
Withdrawing at the first motion versus the second
The distinction that decides most disputes is not the label on the form but the point on the timeline at which consent is withdrawn. Before the second motion is moved, a party may withdraw consent and the court must dismiss the petition. At the second motion, the court hears the parties to satisfy itself that consent subsists; if a party withdraws consent there, the court should not pass the decree, because the statutory requirement of a motion by both parties, and of subsisting consent, is not met. After the decree is pronounced, withdrawal is not a remedy at all, and the remedy is an appeal.
In practice the safer course for a party who is unsure is to file a written application to withdraw before the listing of the second motion, and to appear in person to state the withdrawal. A bare non-appearance on the day of the second motion is a weaker signal, because the court may adjourn and give further opportunity. The strongest protection is a prompt, recorded withdrawal, ideally supported by an affidavit that sets out the reason, whether that is a change of mind about the settlement or pressure that has since become clear.
| Stage | Can consent be withdrawn? | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| After the first motion, before the second motion is moved | Yes | Court dismisses the petition; the other party may file afresh or proceed on fault grounds |
| On the date of the second motion, before the decree | Yes in principle, but contested | Decree should not be passed; the court records the withdrawal and dismisses the petition |
| After the second motion is heard and the decree is passed | No | Remedy is an appeal against the decree, not withdrawal |
What happens if one party stops attending
Non-appearance is the commonest form of withdrawal in practice, and it is also the messiest. If one spouse simply does not appear for the second motion, the court cannot record the satisfaction the section requires, and the petition will not ripen into a decree. What happens next depends on how the court treats the absence. Some courts dismiss the petition for non-prosecution; others adjourn, issue notice, and give further opportunity. Where a party has appeared at the first motion and then withdraws consent in writing, the position is clean and the petition is dismissed on that ground.
For the party who wants the divorce, the options after a dismissal are limited and should be chosen deliberately. One option is to file a fresh consent petition if the other spouse may yet agree, remembering that the separation period still has to be satisfied and the six-month interval may run again. Another is to withdraw the consent petition and file a contested petition under Section 13(1) on cruelty, desertion or another fault ground. A third, on the facts, is to seek the court's help on maintenance and custody in the interim, so that a client is not left without financial support while the matrimonial position is unresolved. Our guide to maintenance for a wife in Hyderabad explains the interim route. Where the separation has already lasted and reconciliation is impossible, a fresh consent petition is usually the faster and cheaper path if the other side can be brought back to the table, which is why the terms of the settlement often need re-negotiating rather than the law needing changing.
The same rule under other statutes
Section 13B applies to Hindu, Buddhist, Jain and Sikh couples. The other personal-law consent routes use comparable language, and the Sureshta Devi principle has been applied to them. Section 28 of the Special Marriage Act, 1954 gives a two-motion consent route with a cooling interval, and the same reasoning on withdrawal applies. Section 10A of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869, inserted in 2001, provides a joint-petition route for Christians, with a two-year separation requirement unless the court reads it down. Section 32B of the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936 provides consent divorce on a one-year separation, in a single suit, and the court there must be satisfied that consent was not obtained by force or fraud. In each, the common thread is the same: consent must survive to the decree.
Practical steps and pitfalls
If you are the party who wants to withdraw, do three things quickly: tell your advocate, file a written application or affidavit before the second motion is listed, and appear in person to state the withdrawal. Do not rely on silence. If you are the party who wants the divorce, protect yourself against a late withdrawal. Do not complete the money transfer or hand over stridhan before the decree unless the settlement provides an enforceable interim arrangement; put a default clause in the settlement; and keep a contemporaneous record of the other party's participation, because a party who negotiates, attends and signs is in a poor position to allege duress on the day of the second motion. And remember the eighteen-month outer limit on the second motion: a consent petition that drifts past it needs an application explaining the delay, and practitioners differ on whether a fresh petition is not the safer course.
Finally, read the first-motion order carefully before it is signed. It should record that consent was verified from both sides and should set out the settlement terms in full or by reference to an annexure. A first-motion order that is silent on maintenance or the children leaves those issues hostage to a later withdrawal. Our guide to the Section 13B second motion and our divorce guide cover the mechanics of filing and the cooling period in more detail.
Frequently asked questions
Can one spouse withdraw consent to a mutual consent divorce?
Yes. Under Section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, mutual consent must subsist until the decree is passed, and either party may unilaterally withdraw consent before then. This was settled in Sureshta Devi v Om Prakash (1991) 2 SCC 25. Once consent is withdrawn, the court has no jurisdiction to grant a divorce by consent.
What is the effect of Section 13B(2) once the second motion is moved?
The second motion must be by both parties, and the court must then be satisfied that the averments are true and that consent was not obtained by force, fraud or undue influence. If consent has gone by that stage, the court should not pass the decree, because the statutory requirement of subsisting mutual consent is not met.
Does withdrawal at the first motion differ from the second motion?
Yes. Before the second motion is moved, a withdrawal normally results in the petition being dismissed. At or just before the second motion, the withdrawal is contested and the court must decide whether consent subsisted. After the decree, withdrawal is not available at all, and the remedy is an appeal.
What if my spouse simply stops attending the hearings?
Without both parties joining the second motion, the court cannot record the satisfaction the section requires, and the petition will not become a decree. The court may dismiss the petition for non-prosecution or adjourn and issue notice. A written withdrawal is cleaner than a bare absence, and the party who wants the divorce may have to file afresh or move to a contested petition.
Can the Supreme Court still dissolve the marriage if consent is withdrawn?
In exceptional cases the Supreme Court may use its power under Article 142 to dissolve a marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown, as in Ashok Hurra v Rupa Bipin Zaveri (1997) and Shilpa Sailesh v Varun Sreenivasan (2023). That is not available to a Family Court, so before a Family Court a withdrawn consent still defeats a Section 13B petition. See also our guide on how to file a mutual divorce in India.
Has your consent divorce stalled?
Advocate Maryam Fatima advises on withdrawal of consent, fresh consent petitions and contested divorce before the Hyderabad Family Court, and drafts settlements that protect you at every stage. Consultations in English, Hindi and Urdu. Call now on +91 96358 75831.