Hyderabad, Telangana

Hindu Law · Hyderabad

Prohibited Relationships and Void Hindu Marriages

Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 forbids a marriage between persons who are sapindas of each other, or within the degrees of prohibited relationship, unless a custom governing both of them permits it. A marriage that breaks either rule is void under Section 11 and can be declared a nullity, while the defects listed in Section 12 make a marriage voidable at the instance of one spouse. The distinction is not academic. It decides whether the marriage needs to be annulled at all, whether the wife can claim a share in her husband's coparcenary property, and what the children inherit. This guide sets out the two relationship rules, the conditions in Section 5, and the consequences of each kind of defect.

What the law actually prohibits

Two different rules sit side by side in Section 5. Clause (iv) bars a marriage between persons within the degrees of prohibited relationship. Clause (v) bars a marriage between persons who are sapindas of each other. They overlap, but they are not the same test: the prohibited degrees are a fixed list of relationships, while sapinda relationship is a generational rule that reaches further up the family tree on the father's side than on the mother's.

Both clauses end with the same proviso: the bar does not apply where a custom or usage governing each of the parties permits a marriage between them. The custom must govern both parties, not one. That single word decides many cases, because a family custom proved by elders of the bride's community does not help if the groom's community has no such custom.

Sapinda relationship under Section 3(f)

Section 3(f) defines sapinda relationship in two steps. Two persons are sapindas of each other if one is a lineal ascendant of the other within the limits of sapinda relationship, or if they have a common lineal ascendant who is within those limits with reference to each of them. The limits are then stated: the relationship extends, in the case of any person, as far as the third generation inclusive in the line of ascent through the mother, and the fifth generation inclusive in the line of ascent through the father. The person concerned is counted as the first generation.

Working the rule out is mechanical once the family tree is drawn. On the father's side the bar reaches five generations up, which catches relationships that most families would not think of as close. On the mother's side it reaches three. Two people who share a great-great-grandfather in the paternal line are within sapinda relationship even though they may never have met. Two people related only through the maternal line become outside the rule sooner.

Degrees of prohibited relationship under Section 3(g)

Section 3(g) lists the relationships that are within prohibited degrees: where one party is a lineal ascendant of the other; where one was the wife or husband of a lineal ascendant or descendant of the other; where one was the wife of the brother, or of the father's or mother's brother, or of the grandfather's or grandmother's brother of the other; and where the two are brother and sister, uncle and niece, aunt and nephew, or the children of two brothers, of two sisters, or of a brother and a sister.

The last clause is the one that surprises people. First cousins are within the degrees of prohibited relationship, and a marriage between the children of a brother and a sister is caught just as squarely as one between the children of two brothers. The bar applies whether the cousin is related through the father or the mother. Where the families can prove a custom permitting such marriages, the marriage is valid; where they cannot, it is void.

Marriage Classification Consequence
Either party has a spouse living Void, Section 11 Nullity decree; bigamy is also an offence
Sapinda or prohibited relationship Void, Section 11 Nullity, unless custom governs both parties
Unsoundness of mind at the time of marriage Voidable, Section 12(1)(b) Valid until annulled on the petitioner's application
Impotence Voidable, Section 12(1)(a) Annulment on the petitioner's application
Consent obtained by force or fraud Voidable, Section 12(1)(c) Time limit of one year from the force ending or fraud being discovered
Respondent pregnant by another at the time of marriage Voidable, Section 12(1)(d) Annulment, subject to the conditions in Section 12(2)
Bride below eighteen or groom below twenty-one Not void under the Hindu Marriage Act Voidable under Section 3 of the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006

The five conditions in Section 5, and the custom exception

Section 5 states the conditions for a valid Hindu marriage: neither party has a spouse living; neither party is an idiot or a lunatic at the time of marriage; the groom has completed twenty-one years and the bride eighteen; the parties are not within the degrees of prohibited relationship unless custom permits; and the parties are not sapindas of each other unless custom permits. Breach of the first, fourth and fifth conditions makes the marriage void under Section 11. Breach of the second makes it voidable under Section 12(1)(b). Breach of the age condition is dealt with by the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006, not by a declaration of nullity under the Hindu Marriage Act.

Custom is proved, not asserted. A party relying on it must show that the custom is ancient, certain, reasonable, continuous and binding on both communities, and that it has been observed as of right. Evidence usually comes from elders, community records, entries in the family's own genealogy and, where available, standard works on the customs of the community. A single instance within one family proves nothing.

Void marriages and voidable marriages

A void marriage under Section 11 is invalid from the beginning. In strict theory no decree is needed to end it, but Section 11 provides for a decree of nullity, and in practice the decree is what the parties need: for a corrected marital status, for remarriage, for records and for the custody and maintenance directions that accompany the order. Until that decree is passed, the marriage continues to be treated as subsisting for many practical purposes, and a spouse who needs certainty should apply rather than assume.

A voidable marriage under Section 12 is valid unless and until it is annulled on the application of the aggrieved spouse. The grounds are impotence, unsoundness of mind at the time of the marriage, consent obtained by force or fraud, and pregnancy by another person at the time of the marriage. Section 12(2) imposes limits: a petition on the ground of force or fraud must be filed within one year of the force ceasing or the fraud being discovered, and no petition lies where the petitioner has lived with the other party with full knowledge of the facts. A voidable marriage that is never annulled produces a valid marriage and legitimate children.

Children, legitimacy and property

Section 16 is the provision that prevents the law from visiting the parents' defect on the children. A child of a marriage that is void under Section 11, or voidable and annulled under Section 12, is legitimate, provided the marriage was solemnised and the child would have been legitimate had the marriage been valid. The child is entitled to succeed to the property of both parents. What Section 16(3) denies is a wider claim: the child's rights are confined to the property of the parents, and do not extend to the coparcenary or joint family property of the parents' family. So a child of a void second marriage shares in the father's own assets, but not in the ancestral coparcenary as a coparcener.

For the woman in a void marriage the position is narrower than that of a wife in a valid marriage. She has no right to maintenance as a matter of personal law, no right of residence in the shared household as a wife, and no share in the husband's coparcenary property. In a proceeding under the Act, however, Section 25 allows the court to order maintenance, and the court's power is not confined to marriages that are valid; maintenance can also be sought in separate proceedings under the general law, decided on the evidence about the relationship and dependency. The practical lesson is that a woman in a suspected void marriage should claim maintenance in the nullity proceeding itself, where the court already has jurisdiction over both parties.

How the question is decided in court

A petition for a declaration of nullity is filed under Section 11 before the Family Court, with the same formal requirements as a divorce petition: the parties, the marriage, the ground, and a prayer for a decree of nullity with consequential orders on custody and maintenance. Jurisdiction follows Section 19. The evidence is genealogical and documentary: horoscopes, family pedigrees, birth and death records, photographs of the wedding, the invitation card, and the testimony of elders who can place the common ancestor. Where custom is pleaded, the evidence must address both families, and the burden stays on the party asserting the custom.

Two practical warnings. First, do not confuse a void marriage with a marriage that is merely irregular or unregistered; registration is evidentiary, not constitutive, and an unregistered marriage can still be valid. Second, delay matters. Section 23(1) requires the court to refuse relief where the petitioner is taking advantage of his or her own wrong or where there has been unnecessary or improper delay, and a nullity petition filed years after the parties separated invites exactly that objection.

Frequently asked questions

Can first cousins marry under Hindu law?

Only where a custom or usage governing both parties permits it. Section 3(g) places first cousins within the degrees of prohibited relationship, so the marriage is void under Section 11 unless the custom is proved. The custom must bind both families, not just one.

What is the difference between sapinda and prohibited relationship?

Sapinda relationship is a generational rule: three generations up the mother's line and five up the father's, with the person counted as the first generation. Prohibited relationship is a list of specific relationships, including first cousins, uncle and niece, and certain affinal relations.

Are children of a void marriage illegitimate?

No. Section 16 makes them legitimate where the marriage was solemnised and they would have been legitimate in a valid marriage. Their inheritance is confined to the property of their parents under Section 16(3), and does not extend to the family's coparcenary property.

Do I need a court decree to end a void marriage?

The marriage is invalid in law without a decree, but a decree of nullity under Section 11 is what establishes your status for remarriage, records and custody. Until it is passed, the relationship may still be treated as subsisting for many purposes, so filing is the practical course.

Can a wife in a void marriage claim maintenance?

She cannot claim maintenance as a wife under personal law, and she has no share in coparcenary property. Section 25 of the Act allows the court to order maintenance in a proceeding under the Act, and claims can also be pursued under the general law. Claim it in the nullity petition itself.

Is your marriage valid? Get the relationship checked properly.

Advocate Maryam Fatima advises on nullity, sapinda and prohibited relationship questions, and appears before the Family Court at Hyderabad. Consultations are available in English, Hindi and Urdu.

Call +91 96358 75831

Keep reading

Related legal guides

More answers on the same area of family law, written for clients in Hyderabad.

Browse all legal guides →

Call WhatsApp Book Visit