Domestic Violence · Hyderabad
What Happens If a Protection Order Is Broken
Breaking a protection order or an interim protection order passed under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 is a criminal offence under Section 31, punishable with imprisonment up to one year, or a fine up to twenty thousand rupees, or both. The offence is cognizable and non-bailable, so the police can register a case and arrest without a warrant. What turns a violation into a conviction is evidence of the order, proof that it was served, and a dated account of what the respondent did next. This guide sets out the offence, the procedure, and what a wife should record after each violation.
What a protection order actually prohibits
A protection order under Section 18 is the core remedy of the Act. The Magistrate may prohibit the respondent from committing or abetting any act of domestic violence; from entering the place where the aggrieved person resides, or her workplace, or the school of her children; from attempting to communicate with her; from alienating any asset, whether stridhan, jointly held property, or a bank account operated by either of them; and from causing violence to her relatives, dependants or anyone who gives her assistance. The order may add any other direction the facts require.
Orders are often passed before the respondent has appeared. Section 23 permits ex parte and interim orders where the Magistrate is satisfied that the application discloses domestic violence and that an immediate order is necessary to prevent further harm. An interim protection order is as enforceable as a final one, and Section 31 applies to a breach of either. A common misconception is that an ex parte order may be ignored until the respondent is heard; it cannot. The remedy for an unfair order is an application to vary it, not disobedience.
Read the order itself, not the section. Liability attaches to what was actually prohibited, and Magistrates word these directions differently. An order restraining entry is not breached by a phone call; an order restraining all communication is. That distinction is often the difference between an acquittal and a sentence.
Section 31: the offence and the punishment
Section 31(1) provides that a breach of a protection order, or of an interim protection order, by the respondent is an offence under the Act, punishable with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to one year, or with fine which may extend to twenty thousand rupees, or both. It is a magisterial offence, tried summarily in practice, and the maximum sentence is modest because the Act is designed to stop conduct rather than to punish it heavily.
Section 31(2) directs that the offence shall, as far as practicable, be tried by the Magistrate who passed the order that was breached. That is deliberate: the judge who made the order knows what it required, and the complainant does not have to educate a fresh court about the history of the case. Where the original Magistrate has been transferred, the successor court hears it and the record travels with the file.
Section 31(3) allows the Magistrate, while framing charges for the breach, to also frame charges under Section 498A IPC, now Section 85 BNS, or under the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, where the facts disclose those offences. This is how a single incident of forced entry or a threatening call can become a prosecution under three statutes at once. A breach is therefore not a light matter simply because the punishment under Section 31 is under two years.
The section speaks of protection orders and interim protection orders. Where the order breached is a residence order under Section 19 or a monetary relief order under Section 20, the usual remedy is enforcement of that order rather than a Section 31 prosecution, though continuing dispossession in defiance of a residence order has also been treated as a breach. In practice the complainant should plead the specific order said to be violated, and the court decides whether Section 31 applies to it. For the orders themselves, see residence orders under the Domestic Violence Act.
Cognizable and non-bailable: arrest without warrant
Section 32(1) provides that, notwithstanding anything in the Code of Criminal Procedure, the offence under Section 31(1) is cognizable and non-bailable. Two consequences follow: the police can register an FIR and investigate without a Magistrate's order, and can arrest without a warrant. Being non-bailable, release is a matter for the court, not the police station.
The power to arrest is not a duty to arrest. The offence carries a maximum of one year, which places it within the class for which Section 35(3) BNSS requires a notice of appearance where arrest is not necessary, and Section 35(1)(b) requires the grounds of arrest to be recorded in writing. The Arnesh Kumar principles, applied to offences punishable up to seven years, are directly relevant. A police officer who arrests a respondent on a bare allegation, without recording why custody is needed, is exposed both in the bail application and in departmental complaint.
A breach complaint registered promptly, with the order and proof of service attached, moves quickly. One filed weeks later without the order annexed is often treated as a matrimonial quarrel and sent to counselling. The Protection Officer can be asked to record the incident and forward a report, which gives the police an official document rather than a private grievance. The wider framework is in the domestic violence guide.
How a breach is documented and proved
Section 32(2) is the provision that shapes every breach case: upon the sole testimony of the aggrieved person, the court may conclude that an offence under Section 31(1) has been committed by the accused. The complainant need not produce an eyewitness, but the testimony must be credible, consistent and tied to dates; an account that cannot say when the respondent came, what he said, or who saw him is not testimony a court can act on.
The table shows what to collect after a breach and what each document does in court. The first two entries matter most, because a breach case fails at the threshold if the court is not satisfied the respondent knew of the order.
| Document | What it proves | How to preserve it |
|---|---|---|
| Certified copy of the protection order | The exact prohibition said to be violated | Apply for a certified copy the day the order is passed |
| Proof of service or acknowledgement | That the respondent knew of the order | Signed acknowledgement, postal proof, Protection Officer report |
| Dated incident note | Sequence and consistency of the account | Write it the same day; keep the original, not a retyped version |
| Police complaint or FIR copy | Contemporaneous report and the date of first complaint | Insist on a receipt and a free copy of the FIR |
| Medical record | Injury, where the breach involved force | Government hospital, with the history recorded |
| Messages, call records, CCTV | Communication prohibited by the order | Screenshots with visible date, device backup, written request to the society for footage |
| Statements of neighbours or relatives | Corroboration of presence and conduct | Record early, while recollection is fresh |
What to do the same day
If a protection order has been breached, safety comes before paperwork. If there is a threat of violence, leave the premises or call the police control room; if there is injury, go to a government hospital and have the history recorded, because a wound that is photographed four days later is worth much less. Do not confront the respondent to establish a point, and do not ask neighbours to intervene in a way that places them at risk.
Then make the record official in the right order. Inform the Protection Officer so that a domestic incident report is created. File a written complaint at the police station having jurisdiction, keep the acknowledgement, and ask for a copy of the FIR. File an application before the Magistrate who passed the order, under Section 31 or seeking further directions, annexing the order, the service proof and the incident note. A woman who does all three within a week is in a far stronger position than one who explains the delay at the hearing.
If the order has become unworkable, ask for it to be varied rather than ignored. Section 25 permits the Magistrate to alter, modify or revoke an order on a change in circumstances, and Section 29 gives a right of appeal to the Sessions Court within thirty days. An interim maintenance or residence arrangement that no longer fits the facts should be corrected by application. Shelter and interim support options are set out in shelter homes and protection in Hyderabad.
What he will argue at the hearing
The first question in any Section 31 case is knowledge. A person cannot be convicted of disobeying an order he was never served with, and the prosecution must establish service or actual knowledge. A respondent who says he was never served will be asked for his address history, and the court will call for the service record.
The second question is whether the conduct falls within the prohibition. Orders are specific, and a breach case must identify the clause violated. Where the order restrained entry into the residence and the allegation is a phone call, there is no breach of that clause. Where the order restrained all communication, even a single message about a child's school fee breaches it on the letter of the order.
Frequently asked questions
Can the police arrest immediately for breaching a protection order?
Yes. Section 32(1) makes the offence cognizable and non-bailable, so an FIR can be registered and an arrest made without a warrant. That said, arrest is not compulsory for an offence carrying one year, and the officer must record why custody is necessary.
Can a breach be proved by her testimony alone?
Section 32(2) allows the court to conclude from her sole testimony that the offence was committed. It is a permission, not a presumption: the court still assesses credibility, and an accused can show contradictions, an alibi or a record that the alleged act did not occur. Corroboration helps the complainant, but its absence is not fatal.
What is the punishment for a first breach?
Up to one year of simple or rigorous imprisonment, or a fine up to twenty thousand rupees, or both. A first breach often attracts a fine and a short sentence, but a repeat breach, or one involving force, will ordinarily attract custody and may add charges under Section 85 BNS.
Does the order end if I move out of the house?
No. A protection order restrains conduct, not residence, and it continues until it is varied or discharged. Moving out satisfies a residence direction but does not lift the bar on communication, alienation of assets or contact with her relatives. Only the court can modify or revoke the order on an application under Section 25.
Can I be punished for breach and for cruelty at the same time?
Yes. Section 31(3) allows the Magistrate to frame charges under Section 85 BNS or the Dowry Prohibition Act while framing charges for the breach, where the same facts disclose those offences. The breach case then runs alongside the cruelty case, and the sentence in one is considered alongside the other.
Protection order breached, or a breach alleged against you?
Advocate Maryam Fatima appears in protection order, breach and variation matters before the Magistrates in Hyderabad, and advises on the record needed on either side. Consultations are available in English, Hindi and Urdu.
Call +91 96358 75831